Academic Integrity Policy (CSE546)
For this class, I am adopting the Academic Integrity Policy that is
most common across this department, and recently made explicit in this
document by Jeremy Buhler. This document outlines the course policy
on academic integrity and collaborations on homeworks. It is posted on
the course web site for your reference. You must read this document at
the beginning of the course and sign a statement with each assignment
indicating that you have complied with the policy. If you are
uncertain as to how to comply with this policy, please ask me.
1. Collaboration with Other Students
In general, verbal discussion of ideas, general approaches, etc. with
other students is permitted. Theory courses aren't much fun if you
can't talk about your ideas! However, each student's written work is
expected to be entirely her or his own. The following rules try to
balance the desire for free discussion with my need to assess each
student's individual capability.
- Please keep group discussions of the homework problems to no more
than three people, all of whom are participating. In larger groups,
there is an unavoidable tendency for some people to "lurk" and pick up
hints on the problems, without actually contributing to their own or
anyone else's understanding of the material.
- If you discuss an assignment with another student, neither party
may carry any written material or code away from the discussion. In
particular, you may not collaboratively write homeworks. This rule
also means that you can't save email from a discussion to refer to
later while writing your solutions.
- You may not share your previously written material as part of a
discussion. In particular, you may not read someone else's written
solutions or code or give your own solutions or code to someone else
to read unless both of you have already turned in your assignments.
- The "Iron Chef" Rule: if you discuss a problem with another
student, you must then go do something completely unrelated for at
least one hour before writing any part of your own solution. For
example, go watch an episode of Ryori no Tetsujin, a.k.a. Iron Chef
(Allez cuisine!). In my experience, this rule is really helpful for
differentiating what you actually understand from what you've merely
cached in your short-term memory. In the interests of full
disclosure, I should say that I borrowed this rule from a former
professor of mine, who called it the "Gilligan's Island" Rule.
I ask that you please honor the spirit as well as the letter of these
rules. Please try to do as much of the assignments as you can on your
own before seeking help from your peers. Don't just tell other
students how to solve a problem, or lead them to the solution via
"hints"; instead, look at the practice problems together to explain
the principles of how to solve the problem. If you ever feel
uncomfortable discussing your work, or you don’t see how to help
someone without simply giving away answers, please refer them to the
TAs or to myself rather than trying to sort things out on your own
Keep in mind that your performance on exams constitutes about half
your course grade, so it ultimately does you no good to let other
people do your assignments for you without learning the
material. Conversely, you're not doing your fellow students a favor by
helping them do their assignments without learning the material.
Finally, I'd like to add that people have in the past gotten
themselves in trouble by copying down from memory code or partial
solutions shown to them by a friend. The graders will see everyone's
assignments and so will catch this sort of thing. The rules about not
sharing written work, as well as the Iron Chef Rule, are supposed to
prevent such (often unintended) copying, so please follow them!
2. Acknowledging Sources of Assistance
Each time you turn in a homework, you are required to list any sources
of assistance you received in solving the problems. Please specify
where you got help and what kind of help you received. I have posted
an assignment cover sheet to help you remember what to turn in. In
general, you may use your course text, the TA, myself, and any written
materials we provide to help you with your assignments. You may not
use any of the following sources:
- previous years' solutions to homeworks or exams;
- solutions, code, or worked examples from other written sources
(e.g. web sites) that solve a problem equivalent or highly similar to
one appearing on an assignment;
- blogs, newsgroups, or other assemblages of "experts".
- "For Hire" sites like rent-a-coder.
As an exception to the above rules, you can use whatever reference
material you want to answer general questions about discrete math and
proof techniques.
Discussions with friends who aren't currently taking the course, other
faculty, your mother, Don Knuth, Alan Turing (if you can find a good
medium), etc. are subject to the rules and guidelines outlined in the
previous section. You must tell the other person in advance that the
discussion pertains to a current course assignment, and you must
report the help received.
3. Sanctions
In cases where a student is found to have violated the course
collaboration policy, the minimum penalty is loss of credit equal to
200% of the assignment on which the violation occurred. For example,
if an assignment is worth 10% of your grade, you will receive no
credit for the assignment and an additional 10% off your final grade.
At the instructor’s discretion, more severe penalties may be given for
particularly egregious or repeated violations, including failure of
the course and such other disciplinary actions as warranted and
allowed by Washington University. Incidents of known or suspected
cheating are also recorded permanently by the CSE Department and may
affect your ability to graduate.
For Ph.D. students, suspected incidents of cheating may be referred to
the Graduate School to be handled via their Academic Integrity Policy.
Note that claiming that you "forgot" to attribute a source is not a
mitigating circumstance. It is your responsibility to describe where
you got help in doing your homework.