Prof. Chenyang Lu
at 10am on the due date. Hard
deadline (no late critique will be
text in the body of your message. No attachment unless you
have to use figures.
- E-mail TA with subject:
[Critique #Number] Full Name. For example: [Critique #1] Chenyang Lu
- About half a page
of ideas/comments - not complete essays.
to hear your own thoughts. Do not simply summarize the paper.
- Identify open
issues and limitations of the paper (think of yourself as a reviewer or a researcher on the same subject).
assumptions reasonable and realistic?
the solution practical?
errors and limitations?
problems with the experimentation?
support the claims?
ways to improve the work?
does the work relate to the other topics previously
covered in class?